US-based activist short-seller Viceroy Research has released a damning report on Vedanta Resources Ltd (VRL), the parent company of Vedanta Ltd (VEDL), accusing it of operating a business model that “resembles a Ponzi scheme.” The report claims that VRL is financially unstable and structurally compromised, relying on continuous borrowing and extraction of funds from its subsidiaries to stay afloat.
Viceroy Research alleges that the parent entity behaves like a “parasite,” drawing liquidity from Vedanta Ltd to repay its mounting debt, effectively hollowing out the publicly listed arm. The report argues that the group’s entire debt structure is unsustainable, and it questions the company’s long-term solvency. According to Viceroy, Vedanta’s liquidity depends largely on aggressive cash pulling from its operating businesses, including Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL), a significant cash-generating entity under the group umbrella.
The report further points to complex corporate structures, opaque related-party transactions, and high leverage as warning signs, comparing VRL’s financial architecture to that of a pyramid reliant on continuous inflows to cover past obligations, an allegation that intensifies investor and regulatory scrutiny.
Market Reaction and Investor Anxiety
Following the publication of the Viceroy Research report on July 9, Vedanta Ltd shares experienced heavy intraday selling, plunging nearly 8% before settling around 3.3% lower at ₹441.30 on the National Stock Exchange (NSE). Hindustan Zinc shares also declined by 2.5%. The broader Nifty Metal index dipped by 1.38%, reflecting wider concern across the sector.
The timing of the report, just ahead of potential restructuring and debt refinancing milestones, further rattled investor sentiment. While Vedanta’s stock attempted a marginal recovery the following day, trading volumes remained high, suggesting elevated levels of uncertainty. Analysts believe the market will now demand stronger evidence of financial discipline and debt reduction strategies from the group in the coming quarters.
Vedanta’s Rebuttal and Ongoing Concerns
In response, Vedanta Ltd issued a strongly worded statement dismissing the Viceroy Research report as “malicious, baseless, and misleading.” The company stated that the report selectively used public data to craft a false narrative aimed at undermining its reputation and disrupting business continuity. Vedanta added that the Viceroy had not contacted company officials before publishing the report and accused the firm of attempting to incite panic among investors and creditors.
Calling the report “a sensationalised attack,” Vedanta emphasized its commitment to transparency and financial integrity. The group is currently undergoing a demerger process initiated in 2023 to simplify its structure and unlock value, which some market participants believe may help address underlying investor concerns, provided it is executed with clear governance standards.
Despite Vedanta’s rebuttal, the Viceroy Research report has reignited broader concerns about corporate debt management among large Indian conglomerates, especially in the wake of recent short-seller-led controversies involving other major firms.
Visit more of our news! Business Viewpoint Magazine.
Sources:
